Have a (chunky lola) cookie!

Tomorrow is a cookie swap party at my work and somehow I thought it was a good idea to participate. What can I say, I love a good excuse to use my new Flour Bakery cookbook!

I had a plan – I was going to make the cookies smaller, calculate their Weight Watchers Points+ and track the 1 cookie I was going to try for quality control.


After Alicia raved about them, I decided to make the chunky lola cookies from the Flour Bakery cookbook. I used a 1.5T cookie scoop instead of 1/4 cup (making them almost 3 times smaller than they are at the bakery!) and used unsweetened coconut (I almost skipped the coconut. If you have the cookbook and make these – don’t skip the coconut! It’s amazing).

So back to my plan… I made exactly 24 cookies required for the cookie swap party + 1 for me and 2 for Adam. Each of my smaller cookies calculated to 3 Points+ – not too bad and these are REAL cookies, with real butter, sugar, chocolate chips, pecans and coconut. The whole deal. It IS possible to enjoy a cookie and stay on plan.


I ate one. It was crispy on the outside with a buttery crumb that instantly melted in my mouth. Heaven! Then I had a few bites of cookie dough (let’s call it cookie #2). This is when I knew it was time to WALK AWAY FROM THE COOKIES.


I did. And then Adam only had one of his (even though he said they were incredible) so I ate the other. That’s 3 cookies, also known as 10 Points+ and 9 points above my daily allowance. I never made it to the gym.

Guys, I’m going to be in so much trouble at the cookie swap party tomorrow. I get weak in the knees just thinking about all that glorious sugar!

Can you stop at just one cookie?

Related Posts with Thumbnails

21 comments to Have a (chunky lola) cookie!

  • I can totally relate… I went to a cookie swap a few weeks ago. It was dangerous to have all those cookies in my house. I definitely can’t stop at just one cookie. I am such a cookie monster it isn’t even funny. I am making Christmas cookies this week for the family on Saturday and I am praying that I can even show SOME self control!

  • I am glad that you enjoyed them – but I had a HARD time stopping at 1 – and I ate a lot of dough. Did I mention I haven’t joined a gym out here yet? yep – pants getting snug.

    Before you go to the cookie swap, promise yourself a bite of only the cookies you’ve never seen before…..1 bite. take the recipes and then bring your swap cookies to work the next day…..I haven’t stopped baking or cooking – but I have started bringing food to work, and people LOVE it.

  • i have SO much trouble with this… i can sometimes stop with a “taste”, but once i have a full cookie… then it is just two, then just one more… and i have done so much worse than three!

  • No way! I can never just keep it at one. Maybe two but really never one! :)

  • It takes a lot of self control to stop at just one…so I’d have to say that I definitely can’t stop at one! :-)

  • I’ve never been into cookies. It’s cake that I have zero self control over and that’s ten times worse!

  • These are my favorite Flour cookies. I would treat myself to one at the of my shift if I hadn’t had another pastry that day. It was pretty much no contest between the Lolas and the other cookies — though they are all amazing. I would definitely make them smaller at home too… that’s a whole lot of cookie!

  • sister inna

    this is the worst time of the year to be staying on any plan :(
    i feel your pain sistuh
    the space around my desk at work has been magically transformed into ” whatever sugar/ flour/ chocolate anyone sends, put it here area”.

  • I don’t have much of a sweet tooth so I can usually stop at one cookie, but I don’t think I can with yours. I love the texture in there! And I’m assuming that it isn’t too sweet, either.

  • Yum! Coconut is amazing in cookies.
    I’m totally fine to stop at 1 cookie if that’s all I want or if I’m full – and I have no problem eating a few more if I really want them :) I also really enjoy making healthy cookies with little processed sugars and eating a bunch for a snack.

  • Hells no. I find I either stuff myself, or I limit myself and spend the whole time miserable, thinking non-stop about how I want another one.

    You can’t win!

  • The answer to your question is usually not. Cookies are bite size, so you have to have more than one :)

    I hope your cookie swap went well and you made it out of there alive!

  • Masha

    Elina I have been reading your blog for awhile but have never commented. Just wanted to tell you that I really appreciate you being so honest and open in your struggles to lose weight and be a mindful eater. I can really relate!!! Masha

  • These look so good! They must have been a hit at the party!

  • Car

    I can stop at one cookie.

    Only when my tummy is full from the ridiculous amount of cookie DOUGH I’ve already eaten and I really can’t find room for another.

    No joke.

    Loves-dough-more-than-cookies And-this-is-why-I-don’t-make-cookies

  • No WAY can I ever stop at just one cookie. I don’t think I ever have had just one cookie to be honest. It is what it is. We all have our weaknesses.

  • Good idea in making the cookies smaller–then you can feel like you’re having more. As far as worrying about going overboard at the cookie swap, it’s December and I think you can jump right back on board come January and be fine! :-)

  • i’m with cara :) although you got some good tips and i peaked ahead to see how you did, like the approach! i’ll have to remember it when it comes to our cookie exchange…


A sample text widget

Etiam pulvinar consectetur dolor sed malesuada. Ut convallis euismod dolor nec pretium. Nunc ut tristique massa.

Nam sodales mi vitae dolor ullamcorper et vulputate enim accumsan. Morbi orci magna, tincidunt vitae molestie nec, molestie at mi. Nulla nulla lorem, suscipit in posuere in, interdum non magna.